A 51-year-old woman in Malahide, Dublin, was dismissed by the Circuit Civil Court for a personal injury claim of € 60,000, but the judge described it as “opportunistic.”
Judge James Odnoho heard that Malahide’s Seabury Glen’s Leslie Duffy was involved in what barrister Veronica McKinney described as a “minor, slow, minimal collision.”
Duffy said the bus seemed to hit the back of the car, causing soft tissue damage to the cervical, thoracic, and lumbar spine, narrowing the range of movement of the sacral and cervical spine.
In a cross-examination, she said Ms. Machineny, who appeared with Defendant Christina Dowling and her insurance company Allianz with Crowley Miller Soliciters, had a car accident in 2013 and was later indemnified for € 40,000. Told.
Duffy told the court on October 9, 2018 that he left the parking lot in Usher’s Quay, Dublin, and retreated to another car driven by Christina Dowling of Globe at Milltree Park in Ratoath, Meath. ..
Dowling proved that he was traveling 4 km an hour at the time, got out of the car and apologized, and said he was shocked by Duffy’s proceedings.
Duffy told Judge Odnowe that nine days after the accident, he attended Dr. Enda Casey at the Donamede Shopping Center on Donameid Road, Dublin, where he prescribed anti-inflammatory, muscle-relaxing and painkillers.
He also encouraged exercise, she received physiotherapy treatment, and she had participated in Ms Mehnaaz Chan, Swords Physiotherapy, Chapel Lane, Swords Demesne, and Swords several times.
The court heard expert evidence that if Dowling’s car was traveling only 4 km an hour, it was very unlikely that Duffy would suffer an injury or degree of injury.
She told Judge Odnoho that her sister was in the car with her at the time of the accident, but was not injured and was not in court.
Ms. Makinani, who produced Duffy’s secret video coverage allegedly walking along the hills of House, defended her personal injury allegations in full and detail, and she was such a low. He denied that he may have been injured in a shocking collision.
The court heard from engineers that there was no apparent external damage to the rear bumper of Duffy’s 2008 Renault Megane support bar behind the bumper, but it was damaged. Duffy said he received a € 677.60 repair quote from Statewide Towing on Main Street in Rush, Dublin, but has not received any car repairs.
Judge Odnoho dismissed Duffy’s allegations and said she appeared to be very agile in a video walking down the hills of House. He said her influence was minimal, she was opportunistic, and she felt she paid her for her.